I've submitted a ticket. Worth noting now, I've updated my game to 0.9.4 and the server is 0.9.4 so I assumed there would be the chance of everything working after being fresh. But the same issue seems to be happening.
I'm still not getting into my server. Not sure what I'm missing here. My V+ is 0.9.3 and my new server shows 0.9.3 but it's still saying it's incompatible...